A Fearsome Doubt

About the book

Best-selling author Charles Todd has gained a prominent position in the world of mystery writing with his highly praised series featuring Scotland Yard Inspector Ian Rutledge, a former soldier trying to come to terms with his past in the aftermath of World War I. The past comes back to haunt him in a complicated murder case that challenges his integrity and raises questions about the crimes committed in the name of honor, patriotism, and justified retribution.

In 1912, Ian Rutledge witnessed the conviction of a man for the brutal murders of elderly women. Rutledge played a key role in gathering evidence that led to Ben Shaw's execution. After justice was served, Rutledge thought he had put the case behind him. However, Shaw's memory lingered.

Seven years later, the shadow of the past reemerges through Nell Shaw, widow of Ben, who believes she has proof of her husband's innocence. Her conviction puts Rutledge in a difficult position, challenging his reputation and confidence in his own judgement.

Rutledge's reluctance is not just about the case. Another murder draws him back to Kent, where he had recently seen a familiar face amidst a bonfire. As the country prepares to mark the anniversary of the Armistice, Rutledge is forced to confront his lingering wartime trauma while dealing with the present case.

Surrounded by an array of characters including a captivating widow, a resilient woman with a turbulent past, a dying barrister, and an unknown individual, Rutledge faces the burden of shell shock in the form of the haunting voice of Hamish MacLeod, the soldier he executed in the war. As he navigates between two elusive murderers and unravels Ben Shaw's mysterious past, Rutledge finds himself in a perilous position, with danger lurking from unexpected corners.